This noteworthy book joins a developing body of criticism
that examines Victorian conceptions of aging and how the aged are portrayed in
literature and the visual arts. Specifically, Chase's work joins two other
books on its subject that have appeared this year: Esther Liu Godfrey's The January-May Marriage in Nineteenth
Century British Literature and
Kay Heath's Aging by the Book: The Emergence of Midlife
in Victorian England. All three further our understanding of
Victorian ideas about aging and representations of it. In research on the
Victorian era, contributions to humanistic gerontology or age studies (as this
area of criticism has been called) have only recently inspired book-length
efforts, though articles and chapters by critics such as Teresa Mangum in A Companion to Victorian Literature and
Culture and the Handbook of
Humanities and the Aging have been influential and important. So Chase's comprehensive approach is welcome.
Using the "leading cultural manifestations of old age," such as the writing of
Dickens, Trollope, Oliphant, and Wilde, the painting of Victorian artists like
Herbert von Herkomer, and the historiographical representation of Queen
Victoria, Chase examines the "threshold moments and landmark events," such as
the Poor Laws, that "both defined and reflected the aging experience in Britain"
(1). The Victorian era, Chase argues, marks the emergence of old age as an "established 'category' of scientific and political discourse" from which Victorians sought
to "take age into full account" (1, 3). By examining how Victorians thought of
age and tried to manage it, Chase draws the aged from the cultural periphery,
illuminating both the nuances of their portrayals in Victorian culture and the
larger social context that shaped these portrayals.
Portraits of age in the novels of Dickens, Trollope, and
Morris, are situated within larger Victorian social contexts, including the
historical one of almshouses and attempts to pass the Old Age Pensions Act. For
example, Chase reads Dickens's portrayals of aging against what would have
resonated with contemporary readers' consciousness: the growing awareness that
the increasing number of elderly threatened to become an overwhelming financial
burden on the younger generations (28). As Chase shows, many modern readers
detect "sentiment" in Dickens's portrayal of Betty Higden's attempts to escape
the plight of pauperism (that is, the urban and country poorhouses, or
increasingly, insane asylums), and to retain her financial independence (29).
Dickens's original readers, however, "had another context in which to place"
this character, one reflective of the reality that aging intensified the
vulnerabilities of those "whose economic position were precarious at best" (29,
30).
Compared with the work of other nineteenth-century
novelists, Chase finds in the fiction of
Trollope a more wide-ranging selection of characters who have reached mid-life
and beyond. She uses these characters to explain how he uses the "rhythms of
plot" and other "narrative vagaries" to denote age, which may not necessarily
be signified by bodily or chronological markers (65). She then links Trollope's
portrayals of the "instability of age" to the resurgence of the almshouse
movement, which helped to define old age by setting the threshold age for
occupancy (alternatively "50, 55, or 60"), thereby furnishing a topic that
Trollope explores in The Fixed Age (77,
78). Likewise, Chase links the utopian vision of indeterminate age in William
Morris's News from Nowhere to Charles
Booth's attempts to gain the passage of the Old Age Pensions Act, which
exemplified the Victorians' struggle to define both what "healthy old age
[would] look like-physically, socially, economically, politically" and the
economic strain that financially supporting the elderly would potentially
impose upon younger Victorians (245).
Unsurprisingly, the complex and often vexed feelings that
Victorians had towards increasing numbers of the old resulted in equally
complex portrayals of the often seemingly uncanny and strange effects of aging.
As Chase shows, authors like Oliphant and Gaskell use "the supernatural, the
gothic, witches, and madness" in their short fiction to illustrate responses to
aging (113). In their "supernatural tales," Oliphant and Gaskell make heavy use
of elderly women ("playing a part well exceeding the statistical norm") to show
how the aged can "disturb tranquility and . . . frustrate satisfaction" of the
young (124, 128). But in the fiction of Oliphant and Gaskell, episodes of
intergenerational tension haunted by "crones, hags" and "ghosts" alternate with
more realist portrayals of aging (124). In Cranford,
which Chase calls a "landmark text in the affirmation and celebration of
old age," Gaskell's aging women create their own community against the threat
of the dangers of speculation; in Hester,
Oliphant's portrayal of the elderly staunchly resists "a sentimental
reading of the wisdom of age" (138).
According to Chase, the Victorian consciousness of what it
meant to be old grew as much from the specter of an aging Queen as from the
increasing numbers of the old. It may now be difficult to think of Queen
Victoria as anything but a monolithic personification of an era. But as the
Queen aged, she exemplified the experience and impact of aging within the
public sphere. As she grew into an old age intensified by her protracted
grieving for Prince Albert, the "mass distribution of images (photographs,
engravings, cartoons)" that represented and imagined Victoria at all stages of
her life, Chase writes, indicated a "sense of the nation's preoccupation with
its own age" (153, 154). In other words, according to Chase, "Victoria and the
'Victorian age' [became] emblems for the aging process during the last quarter
of the nineteenth century" (160). In the writing of Victoria herself as well as
of Margaret Oliphant (who linked her own "struggles and griefs" to those of
Victoria and who represented aging "as an experience of superfluity and
emptiness" in her Autobiography),
Chase finds a consciousness of the "tediums, miseries, pleasures, and pains"
associated with aging (178, 183, 193). She also connects the public, official
representation of Queen Victoria to "the status of queenship" in Lewis Carroll's
Alice books (162). The aging Queen,
Chase contends, influenced both Carroll's portrayal of female power (in figures
such as Queen Alice) and his treatment of intergenerational conflict, a theme
she also traces in New Woman literature.
As the "aging population became newly visible," Chase
argues, they emerged into "startling new prominence." They take their place in
what Chase calls the era's "portraiture," a term she applies not just to the
painting of artists like Herbert von Herkomer but also to works of fiction such
as Wilde's Picture of Dorian Gray (200).
Dorian's fear of aging, she contends, springs from the fear of its degrading
effect as well as from its "visibility," a factor that, in the case of Dorian,
no matter his attempts, "constantly threatens exposure and humiliation" (Chase
204, 205). Besides exemplifying the link between sinfulness and criminality,
Chase explains, Dorian's turn to crime illustrates, the degeneracy that was
increasingly associated with aging. Since aging is for Chase a bodily
experience that cannot be escaped, she pairs Wilde's creation of a "moral map
of the decaying body" with explicitly visual representations of aging in the
era's fine art. Von Herkomer paintings of the aged-most famously in the
poignant Last Muster-can be seen,
Chase writes, as "signal events in the representation of Victorian age" (219).
His works reveal not only the emerging numbers of the old but also their
economic needs, both of which demanded "large-scale social and systematic
assistance" (223). Paradoxically, their peripheral status enhanced their
salience. Amplifying work done by Godfrey (see above), and Thomas R. Cole and
Claudia Edwards (in their very fine chapter within Pat Thane's A History of Old Age, 2005), Chase
observes that paintings representing the aged often put them on the edges of
the canvas. Their seeming peripherality, however, allows them to offer
commentary on the scene illustrated in the painting and to "often assume
crucial functions, visually and socially" (226). In the works of Stanhope
Forbes, William Powell Frith, and Frank Bromlet, they also take part in
portrayals of intergenerational interaction that show how "tension among the
sexes, classes, and generations might be overcome" (231).
Chase's important text will strongly engage not only hose interested
in the textual and visual portrayals and conceptions of aging in the Victorian
era, but also those who study the era's treatment of other disadvantaged
sectors of the population, including the poor and mentally ill. With Michael
Levenson in a chapter of The Spectacle of
Intimacy (2000), Chase has previously considered how a difference in age
affects marriage in Dickens's "A Cricket on the Hearth." In this book she has
further enriched the study of aging by showing how the Victorians conceived and
represented-in pictures and words-what it meant to be old.
Sarah Bleakney is a
Ph.D. Candidate in English at the University of Florida.